MuSyQ,MODIS和GLASS LAI产品在安徽省的对比分析
Comparative analysis of MuSyQ LAI,MODIS LAI,and GLASS LAI exemplified by Anhui Province
-
摘要: 叶面积指数(leaf area index,LAI)是研究全球碳循环、水循环、能量交换以及气候变化的重要参数之一。目前存在多个不同时间序列和分辨率的LAI产品,对不同产品进行对比分析,不仅可以揭示LAI产品在各区域的适用性,还可以为产品算法的改进提供建议。该文选取安徽省典型样区,从对植被时空特征表征能力方面对MuSyQ LAI、MODIS LAI和GLASS LAI产品的时空一致性进行对比和评价。研究结果表明:①空间上,3种产品空间分布与植被空间分布格局相吻合,空间一致性相对较好,但在LAI大小和空间异质性的表现上存在差异。MODIS LAI值整体高于其他2种产品,MuSyQ LAI值相对GLASS LAI值在耕地和落叶阔叶林地区偏低,在常绿林地区偏高。3种产品随着空间分辨率的提高,空间细节表现力增强,MuSyQ LAI所表征地物分布的空间异质性最显著;②MODIS LAI和GLASS LAI值随高程变化规律较一致,而MuSyQ LAI变化与两者存在差异,3种产品LAI值在低海拔地区随高程增加而增加,在高海拔处变化趋势因样区不同存在差异;③时间上,各产品多年平均的时间序列曲线完整性较好,呈现出相似的季节变化趋势,能很好地表征农作物的物候特征及不同植被的季节变化规律。3种产品时空一致性相对较好,均能反映植被的空间分布特征和时间变化规律,但在LAI大小和空间异质性的表现上存在差异,MuSyQ LAI产品数据更适用于地形复杂、地物分布异质性高的区域年内变化研究,GLASS LAI更适于长时间序列大区域的研究。Abstract: The leaf area index (LAI) serves as an important parameter for investigating the global carbon cycle,water cycle,energy exchange,and climate change. At present,there are multiple LAI products with different time series and resolutions. Comparative analysis of these products can not only reveal their suitability in various regions,but also provide suggestions for optimizing their algorithms. Focusing on the typical areas in Anhui province,this study compared and assessed the spatiotemporal consistency of MuSyQ LAI,MODIS LAI,and GLASS LAI products from the perspective of their capacity to characterize the spatiotemporal characteristics of vegetation. The results indicate that the spatial distribution of LAI obtained from the three products was consistent with the spatial distribution of vegetation,revealing good spatial consistency. However,there existed differences in LAI values and spatial heterogeneity. To be specific,the MODIS LAI displayed generally higher values than the other two products. The MuSyQ LAI exhibited lower values than the GLASS LAI in cultivated land and deciduous broad-leaved forests,but higher values in evergreen forests. As spatial resolution increases,the three products all showed better spatial details,with the MuSyQ LAI featuring the most pronounced spatial heterogeneity in land cover distribution. As the elevation varies,the MODIS LAI and GLASS LAI values vary in a consistent pattern,while the MuSyQ LAI value varies in a different pattern. The three products presented altitude-varying LAI values at low-altitude areas,whereas they showed varying change patterns at high-altitude areas across different sample areas. Temporally,the three products presented relatively complete time-series curves of the annual average LAI value over the years and similar seasonal trends,which can effectively characterize the phenological characteristics of crops and the seasonal variations of different plants. Overall,the three products exhibited good spatiotemporal consistency,all of which can reflect the spatial distribution and temporal changes of vegetation. However,they were different in the LAI value and spatial heterogeneity. Among them,the MuSyQ LAI is more suitable for investigating inter-annual changes in areas featuring complex terrains and high heterogeneity in land cover distribution,while the GLASS LAI is more suitable for long-time-series studies in large areas.
下载: