国土资源遥感, 2019, 31(2): 1-9 doi: 10.6046/gtzyyg.2019.02.01

综述

面向地块的农作物遥感分类研究进展

韩衍欣1,2, 蒙继华,1

1.中国科学院遥感与数字地球研究所数字地球重点实验室,北京 100101

2.中国科学院大学,北京 100049

A review of per-field crop classification using remote sensing

HAN Yanxin1,2, MENG Jihua,1

1.Key Laboratory for Digital Earth Science, Institute of Remote Sensing and Digital Earth, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China

2.University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China

通讯作者: 蒙继华(1977-),男,研究员,主要从事作物遥感监测及精准农业遥感应用方面的研究。Email:mengjh@radi.ac.cn

责任编辑: 张仙

收稿日期: 2018-01-24   修回日期: 2018-03-23   网络出版日期: 2019-06-15

基金资助: 高分辨率对地观测系统重大专项项目“GF-6卫星宽幅相机作物类型精细识别与制图技术”.  09-Y20A05-9001-17/18
“GF-6卫星宽幅相机影像植被参数定量反演技术”.  30-Y20A03-9003-17/18
国家自然科学基金面上项目“基于作物模型与遥感数据同化的农田土壤速效养分反演方法研究”共同资助.  41871261

Received: 2018-01-24   Revised: 2018-03-23   Online: 2019-06-15

作者简介 About authors

韩衍欣(1994-),男,硕士研究生,主要从事农作物遥感分类及长势监测方面的研究。Email:hanyx@radi.ac.cn。 。

摘要

农作物遥感分类是农作物面积监测的核心问题,对于进一步开展农作物长势、产量等专题监测具有重要意义。与同质像元聚类得到的对象相比,地块数据包含了更为精确的位置和面积信息,被越来越多地应用于农作物遥感分类。首先,系统总结了面向地块农作物遥感分类在理论、方法和实践中取得的进展; 然后,分析了该方法目前存在的问题; 最后,对未来的发展趋势进行了展望。研究认为,数字化和影像分割是获取地块数据的主要途径,陆续发布的全国地块数据集也给面向地块农作物遥感分类带来了新的契机; 将面向地块的农作物遥感分类策略分为考虑地块整体特征和以像元为基础2种,并总结了遥感分类特征和分类方法取得的进展; 在未来一段时间,多源数据的应用、地块边界检测技术的发展、分类特征的挖掘以及遥感分类运行化能力的提高将是面向地块农作物遥感分类的重要研究内容。

关键词: 面向地块 ; 农作物 ; 遥感 ; 分类

Abstract

Crop classification using remote sensing is the key to monitoring crop planting acreage and has great significance in further thematic monitoring. As field contains more accurate information of location and acreage than object which is the result of clustering similar pixels, it has been applied to crop classification using remote sensing increasingly. This paper summarizes the progress of per-field crop classification using remote sensing systematically, including its theories, methods and applications. Furthermore, a series of problems are analyzed and future study directions are viewed. Studies show that digitalization and image segmentation are the main approach to obtaining field boundary and more nationwide field database and bringing per-field classification a new opportunity. The strategies of per-field classification can be divided into two categories:using field features as input for the classifier and assigning field class based on per-pixel classification. The progress of features and classifiers in classification with remote sensing data are summarized further. It is indicated that combined application of multi-source data, development of field boundary detection, new features selection and improving implementation capacity of remote sensing image classification will be the crucial issues in per-field classification using remote sensing.

Keywords: per-field ; crop ; remote sensing ; classification

PDF (1056KB) 元数据 多维度评价 相关文章 导出 EndNote| Ris| Bibtex  收藏本文

本文引用格式

韩衍欣, 蒙继华. 面向地块的农作物遥感分类研究进展. 国土资源遥感[J], 2019, 31(2): 1-9 doi:10.6046/gtzyyg.2019.02.01

HAN Yanxin, MENG Jihua. A review of per-field crop classification using remote sensing. REMOTE SENSING FOR LAND & RESOURCES[J], 2019, 31(2): 1-9 doi:10.6046/gtzyyg.2019.02.01

0 引言

我国是一个农业大国,农业问题一直是人们关注的焦点。人口的不断增长和耕地资源的减少,促使我国现代化农业生产向集约化、精准化方向发展[1]。随着这种转变,农业生产过程中对空间信息,特别是动态、大范围、及时快速的农作物信息需求越来越迫切[2]。及时了解农作物空间分布、长势、产量以及农业灾害等信息,对于实现科学管理和农作物增产、辅助政府决策者宏观掌握粮食生产和调控农产品贸易具有重要意义[3,4]

遥感具有覆盖面积大、高效及时、省时省力的优点,能够为农业部门提供及时准确的农田信息,越来越多地应用于农业生产与管理[5]。目前,遥感已经成为精准农业中获取农作物信息的重要手段,在农作物分类[6]、长势评价[7,8]、物候监测[9]、产量估测[10]和农业灾害评估[11]等领域取得了越来越多的成果。农作物种植面积是影响粮食产量的重要因素之一[12],它反映了农业生产资源的情况,是重要的农情信息[13]。了解农作物空间分布信息是开展农作物长势、产量和成熟期等专题监测的前提,而提取这一信息的关键是农作物类型的精确识别,遥感为其提供了丰富的数据和方法[14]。通过遥感快速、准确识别各种农作物类型,对于完善农作物面积监测方法、开展农作物生产水平遥感评估等具有重要意义。

通常,根据分类的基本单元,可以将农作物遥感分类方法分为面向亚像元、像元、对象和地块4种类型[15],这些分类方法在理论、技术方法和实践方面都取得了长足的进展[16,17,18]。传统基于像元的分类仅着眼于局部而忽视地物之间的关联关系,始终存在光谱变异和光谱混合问题,严重影响农作物分类精度[19,20,21],因此许多学者根据农作物种植结构特点,采取以地块为基本单元的分类方式来提高分类精度[2]。面向地块的农作物遥感分类利用真实的地块边界矢量数据,可以解决面向像元分类存在的问题,相对于面向对象分类也更加符合实际。另外,面向地块的农作物遥感分类以地块为核心,有助于针对地块形态特点选择适宜空间分辨率的数据进行分类,降低分类精度对影像空间分辨率的依赖。一系列国情调查的有序推进,全面查清了我国土地利用状况,陆续发布了很多重要的数据成果,其中包括农村土地的范围、类型、面积和权属等数据。随着这些成果的推广应用,地块数据越来越容易获取,给面向地块的农作物遥感分类提供了新的机遇。

本文对面向地块农作物遥感分类的研究进展进行总结,首先,介绍了地块数据获取的现状; 其次,对面向地块分类的分类策略、分类特征和分类方法进行综述和分析,同时指出该方法存在的问题和面临的挑战; 最后,对未来发展趋势进行了展望。

1 地块数据获取的现状

1.1 地块的定义与特点

地块是指具有同一权属主的完整封闭的农田,是农户生产经营的最小单位,是实现农作物生产规划、管理和效益评价的基本单元[22,23]。一般来说,一个地块只种植一种农作物,其边界具有长期稳定性,可以重复多次使用,有利于开展基于地块的农作物遥感分类。地块是一种特殊的对象,面向地块分类正是将遥感影像分为一个个地表真实的“地块”对象并将其作为基本单元进行分类,根据地块内像元的特性统计赋予地块农作物类型,而不只是确定每个像元的类型。地块与普通对象又有所区别,对象是通过对高空间分辨率遥感影像进行分割得到的,它的实质是相对同质像元的集合; 而地块作为一种典型的地理对象,内部除了农作物纯像元外,还可能存在一些混合像元和内部变异。地块与普通对象的另一个区别是边界,对象边界为了与像元边缘保持一致往往呈锯齿状,而现实中的地块边界更加平滑。最后,对象仅针对像元间的同质性进行聚类,是自然的; 而地块经过人工勾绘,与农作物种植实际情况相符,同时也被赋予了更多的社会属性。总的来说,地块在参考像元间关系的基础上,更多地考虑了农作物种植的真实情况,提供了更为准确的边界、地理位置以及面积信息。因此,以地块为基本单元的农作物遥感分类与面积监测在精度和效率上都有很大优势,可以服务于农业普查和农业保险等领域。

1.2 现有的地块提取方法

目前面向地块的农作物遥感分类研究中,地块边界矢量多来自于对卫星影像、地籍数据或拓扑图的数字化[24]。通过专业人员对高空间分辨率影像的目视解译,在考虑像元相近性的基础上引入先验知识,可以更加准确地进行地块边界提取。但是在获取大范围地块边界数据时,人工数字化的方式会耗费大量时间,效率较低。

影像分割技术是获取地块边界的另一种方式,它基于相邻像元之间的光谱异质度及设定的光谱异质阈值对像元进行合并和分割,形成由多个同质像元组成的目标对象[25]。对于同一景影像,通过选择最优分割尺度可以较为准确地提取地块边界,但最优分割尺度的选取比较复杂,它主要受地物类型、周围环境对比度和内部异质性影响[26]。在众多分割算法中,多尺度分割(multiresolution segmentation,MRS)算法应用最为广泛[27,28,29,30],其中由eCognition软件提供的分型网络演化方法(fractal net evolution approach,FNEA)在视觉和数量方面都优于其他MRS算法[31,32]。但是MRS算法中,每一类只能选择一个尺度,它忽略了周围环境和内部异质性的影响,因此还不足以生产出精确的分割结果。另外,用户还需手动选择最优分割参数(包括定义斑块大小的“分割尺度”、多光谱波段“颜色/形状”的权重和斑块紧密程度的“平滑/紧密”)来提升分割效果,而这一过程需要一定的经验,且是相当费时费力的[33]。尽管影像分割技术已有了较大发展,但仍不能像目视解译般准确获取所有地物边界[34],因此自动分割得到的地块边界往往仍需要手动修正才能与实际边界吻合。

1.3 已有的全国地块数据

随着一系列国情普查成果的推广应用,地块边界数据更容易获取[19]。目前的国情普查主要有第二次全国土地调查、第一次全国地理国情普查、第三次全国农业普查和农村土地确权,虽然这些普查工作内容和重点不同,但都针对我国土地情况展开了调查,形成了多种全国范围的地块数据集。

第二次全国土地调查于2009年完成,利用现有土地调查成果和3S技术,以1∶10 000比例尺和5 m图斑采集精度对农村土地进行调查,确定了每块土地的地类、面积、权属和分布信息,形成了最小图斑面积为600 m2的全国各级基本农田的分布数据[35]。2013—2015年第一次全国地理国情普查基于覆盖全国的空间分辨率优于1 m的多源遥感影像数据,开展了地表覆盖调查(包括植被、水体、建筑物及地理单元等的普查),查清了我国农田植被分布情况,地块图斑采集精度和最小图斑面积分别为2.5 m和400 m2[36,37]。第三次全国农业普查的重要内容之一是农作物种植面积遥感测量,查清了我国农村土地利用和流转情况[38]。农村土地确权是指土地所有权、土地使用权和其他项权利的确认、确定,全面开展农村土地确权登记颁证工作,有利于掌握农用地的空间信息和权属信息[39]。在开展普查工作的同时,国家也在建立健全数据共享机制,加强对普查成果的及时转化和广泛利用。随着普查成果的不断发布,越来越多的地块数据实现了共享,将为面向地块的农作物遥感分类提供重要数据支撑。

2 面向地块农作物遥感分类研究进展

面向地块的农作物分类思想最早由Derenyi[40]提出,它为解决像元分类面临的光谱变异和光谱混合问题提供了一个简单有效的解决方案,之后国内外学者开展了大量研究,在面向地块农作物分类领域取得了较大进展。Wit等[34]研究了面向地块思想在运行化农作物遥感监测的精度和效率,结果表明地块边界有效降低了分类误差,总体精度可达85%以上,但是地块边界数字化效率较低; Conrad等[41]利用影像自动分割技术勾绘地块数据,在中亚干旱区开展了面向地块的灌溉作物分类,实现了80%的分类精度; 顾晓鹤等[19]使用不同特征和不同分类器进行面向地块的冬小麦种植面积估算,结果表明基于地块分类的冬小麦总量精度和位置精度均高于像元分类; Löw等[42]根据前人研究选取了多种农作物分类特征,研究了特征选择对面向地块农作物分类精度和空间不确定性的影响。以上研究表明,面向地块的农作物遥感分类切合实际,能够实现较高的分类精度。

2.1 面向地块分类策略

目前,面向地块农作物遥感分类采用的策略主要有2种[34]。一种是将地块看成一个整体,通过像元平均等方式统计地块对象的特征(如平均反射率、平均植被指数、标准差和面积等),根据特征赋予地块不同的农作物类型[43]。顾晓鹤等[19]在开展面向地块的农作物分类时便采用了以上策略,取得了较好的效果。但是从像元尺度转换到地块尺度,训练样本数量会大幅减少,可能导致分类精度下降。另外一种以像元分类为基础,根据像元分类的结果赋予地块农作物类型属性(如将地块内像元占比最高的类别作为该地块农作物类型)。为了分析不同策略面向地块分类的优劣,Kussul等[44]改进了分类策略并对不同分类策略进行了研究。需要注意的是,不管采用哪种策略开展农作物遥感分类,均对地块边界数据的准确性有较高要求。因为在地块边界划分不准确的情况下,一个地块可能包含多种农作物,产生地块尺度的“混合地块”现象,最终会影响农作物的分类精度。

2.2 分类特征选择

2.2.1 分类特征

面向地块与传统面向像元、面向对象的农作物遥感分类相比,可使用的分类特征差别不大,主要包括光谱特征、时相特征和空间特征。不管基于哪种分类单元进行遥感分类,分类特征的选择都是必不可少的,研究学者针对分类特征进行了相关研究。

光谱特征作为农作物遥感分类的物理基础,是农作物生理生化参数和环境因子共同作用的结果,但是农作物遥感识别中普遍存在“同物异谱”和“异物同谱”问题[45]。如图1所示,农作物光谱受叶片内部各种色素(叶绿素为主)和水分含量等因素的影响,呈现出区别于水体、土壤和建筑物等其他地物的独特反射特征。刘亮等[46]充分利用高光谱数据丰富的光谱特征,采用分层分类的方法对北京市顺义区农作物进行了精细识别,各种农作物分类精度达到了95%以上; Löw等[42]通过分析不同特征对面向地块农作物分类精度的影响发现,包含RapidEye红边信息的特征能够有效提高农作物的识别精度; 刘佳等[47]在研究中引入RapidEye红边波段后提高了不同农作物的可分性,总体识别精度提高了6.7%。另外,通过对多波段运算获得的多种指数,如归一化植被指数(normalized difference vegetation index,NDVI)、归一化水体指数(normalized difference water index,NDWI)和三角植被指数(triangular vegetation index,TVI)等特征在面向地块的农作物遥感分类中的应用也很广泛[28]。微波数据可以提供农作物几何特征和土壤水分信息,在农作物生长发育不同时期呈现不同的散射特性,被较多地应用于识别水稻等农作物[48]。Kussul等[44]在开展面向地块分类时,综合使用了Landsat8多光谱数据和Sentinel-1A合成孔径雷达数据,取得了较高的分类精度。

图1

图1   农作物反射光谱特征

Fig.1   Reflectance spectra of crop


时相特征是指农作物在不同时相遥感影像上的变化规律,主要反映了农作物在不同物候阶段的生理生化差异。通过捕获关键物候期的遥感数据,分析农作物不同时期的特征,可以提高目标识别能力和精度。参考时相特征的农作物遥感分类,根据遥感影像数量的多少,主要分为基于单一时相、多时相和时间序列遥感影像3种。Arikan[49]选取多时相Landsat7 ETM+影像,采用先面向像元再面向地块的分类策略进行农作物识别,识别精度比使用单景8月份影像提高了10%以上; Kussul等[50]使用6景Landsat8 OLI影像进行面向地块的分类,在分类时去除云像元的影响,有效提高了分类精度。

此外,遥感影像还可以提供空间特征,最常用的方法是提取影像的纹理特征,例如通过灰度共生矩阵计算的同质性和差异性等。研究表明,地形(高程、坡度、坡向等)和气象(日照、积温、风速、降水量等)等各类专题信息也可以作为辅助数据特征应用到农作物遥感识别中[51]。Bolstad等[52]发现综合利用Landsat TM影像、土壤和地形信息可以获得较基于光谱数据分类更高的精度; 吴炳方等[53]通过将Landsat TM数据划分为各个小区进行局部光谱训练和监督分类,将早稻面积提取精度提高到85%以上,将中稻面积提取精度提高到80%以上。

2.2.2 特征选择

随着遥感技术的不断发展,高时间、高空间分辨率卫星不断涌现,提供了更丰富的地物分类特征,使农作物精细识别成为可能。但在实际应用中,训练样本有限,特征维数并不是越高越好,特征数量增加到某一临界点后,继续增加反而会导致分类精度变低,这种现象被称为“休斯”现象或“休斯”效应[54]。因此,评价各种特征对分类的影响,从大量特征中优选出对分类贡献最大的特征,从而使用最优特征或特征组合识别农作物,可以降低特征提取和分类器的计算复杂度,降低分类结果的不确定性,显著提高农作物分类的效率。根据特征集合与学习算法结合方式的不同,特征选择策略可以分为3类: 过滤式、封装式和嵌入式[55]

过滤式特征选择独立于分类学习算法,由数据集直接求得优化的目标函数,如特征的相关性和可分度等,用搜索算法得到最终的特征子集,最后应用于分类学习算法。过滤式特征选择算法主要有主成分分析法和单变量特征选择法等。王娜等[56]基于单变量特征选择法对光谱特征、波段差值、植被指数和纹理特征等76个特征变量进行优选,分类总体精度达到97.07%,Kappa系数达到0.96,降低特征维度的同时保证了较高的分类精度。过滤式的优点是简单、高效,但容易和后续的分类算法产生偏差,于是出现了封装式的特征选择算法。

封装式策略利用分类器的分类性能来评价特征子集的优劣,在特征空间中筛选出具有较高性能的子集,直接构造分类模型。在封装式的特征选择算法中,有很多用来评价特征子集的学习算法,如遗传算法等,这些算法都是将分类算法性能作为子集的评价标准。该策略中特征选择算法直接成为分类学习算法的一个组成部分,有利于关键特征的辨识,同时准确率比较高。但是该算法在速度上比过滤式慢,时间复杂度较高。

嵌入式特征选择是一种基本的归纳算法,从根本上说是封装式的发展和延伸。嵌入式特征选择是在机器学习的过程中进行的,实现特征分类的方法是增加特征或者减少特征,也可以将不同特征组合。典型的嵌入式特征选择算法主要有支持向量机(support vector machine,SVM)递归特征消除算法以及随机森林算法等。Löw等[42]将随机森林算法作为特征选择策略,通过计算特征重要性得分对71个光谱特征和地学统计特征进行优选,并研究了不同特征对面向地块农作物分类的贡献大小。

2.3 分类方法

农作物遥感分类是一个复杂的过程,分类方法的选择是分类成功的关键。面向地块的农作物分类实质上只是改变了分类的基本单元,而且一些面向地块的分类是以像元分类为基础的,因此在分类方法的使用上与面向像元、面向对象分类是一致的。目前,国内外发展了各种分类技术,针对农作物面积的遥感提取方法除了常规的目视解译,最大似然、最小距离和ISODATA等一些传统的监督、非监督分类方法外,还发展了决策树、随机森林和SVM等很多先进的分类算法。

2.3.1 传统分类器

监督分类是计算机自动进行农作物遥感分类经常使用的一种手段,如美国LACIE计划使用Landsat MSS数据,其中部分结合航空影像,在已知地面样方小麦种植情况和位置的前提下,采用分层监督分类的方法提取小麦的种植面积,达到90%以上的提取精度[57]; Yang等[58]使用SPOT5数据,比较了最小距离、马氏距离、最大似然和光谱角制图等传统监督分类法在农作物分类和面积提取效果上的差异,结果表明最大似然的精度高于其他3种分类方法,最高可达91%。非监督分类方法不需要人工选择训练样本,仅需极少的人工初始输入,计算机自动根据像元光谱或空间等特征组成集群组,然后分类者将每个组与参考数据比较,将其划分到某一类中[59]。长期以来,已经发展了很多非监督分类方法,常用的有ISODATA和K-means分类。Turker等[18]使用非监督分类方法开展面向地块的农作物遥感识别,对比了不同传感器数据下的分类效果,对不同传感器数据的适用场景进行了总结。

2.3.2 决策树与随机森林

决策树是由一系列的二叉树构成的树形分类器,根据规定的判断规则,不断地将影像的像元分割成相对同质的数据子集来确定影像中每个像元所属的正确类型。决策树分类方法具有直观简洁、可行性强、计算量小的特点。并且决策树分类还可以较好地对分类过程和结果进行解释,能够很好地表示不同类型之间的相互关系。Li等[60]基于NDVI时间序列数据,使用决策树进行面向对象的农作物分类,总体精度达到90.87%。

通过改进决策树分类器,获得了很多新的数据挖掘算法,例如分类回归树、C5.0和随机森林。随机森林是由多个决策树组成的组合型分类器,实质是对决策树算法的一种改进,它通过随机等方式建立多个决策树,分类时根据决策树对样本的投票决定样本所属的类型[61]。随机森林能够在有效处理大量数据的同时避免过度拟合,具备训练样本快、分类精度高、抗噪性强等优点,因而被广泛应用于遥感分类领域[62,63]

Bagging是组合型分类器中较为常用的算法,它的基本思想是从原始数据集中随机、独立地产生多个训练子集,然后将每个子集独立地运用于每个分类器,每个分类器对测试样本进行分类,最后将各个分类器的分类结果进行组合[64]。随机森林采用Bagging算法思想,从原始数据集中选取N个训练子集,每个训练子集大小约为原始数据的2/3,剩余的1/3数据作为测试样本,通常被称为袋外数据(out-of-bag,OOB),OOB可以用来估计内部误差,进而预测分类的正确率[61]。根据自助样本集生成的多个决策树组成随机森林,新数据的分类结果根据决策树的投票结果而定。

2.3.3 SVM

SVM是一种非参数分类器,能够解决复杂的分类问题。由于它具有适用于高维特征空间、小样本统计学习、抗噪声影响能力强等特点,因而在遥感分类中得到了广泛应用[65]。如果采取考虑地块整体特征的策略进行面向地块的分类,训练样本会大大减少,这时SVM就可以发挥很大优势。Löw等[42]综合利用随机森林和SVM进行分类,首先根据随机森林重要性得分评价特征,然后选取不同特征进行SVM分类,研究了不同特征对面向地块农作物分类的影响; Gu等[66]对比了SVM和最大似然法的面向地块冬小麦面积监测情况,结果显示SVM分类精度为97%,高于最大似然法的90%,而且面向地块比面向像元能够获得更高、更稳定的分类精度。

3 存在问题

3.1 地块数据获取技术

虽然很多地区的地块数据作为普查成果已经实现了共享,但在不能通过该方式获取地块数据的情况下,矢量化和影像分割是2种常见的获取方式,而这2种方式又各有优缺点。通过对高空间分辨率影像等数据的矢量化可以获得地块边界,这种人工目视解译的方式获得的边界数据往往精度较高,与真实地理实体的重合度较高,但是该方式效率较低,难以在获取大范围地块边界时应用。影像分割技术通过对同质像元的自动聚类,很大程度上提高了获取地块边界的效率。但是,很多分割算法的结果是不可预测的,而且分割时无法将一些环境信息(如地块形状、种植结构等)考虑进去,在大多数情况下无法达到人工识别的准确率。因此,为快速获取准确的地块边界数据,应改进传统技术或发展新的地块边界获取方法。

3.2 地块内部不均一性

地块内部不均一性会对面向地块的农作物遥感分类产生干扰,主要包括2点问题: ①地块与对象的主要区别是地块内部不仅包含同质像元,还存在一些其他像元(地块边界处的混合像元、由长势差异等原因引起的内部变异像元以及受云覆盖影响的像元等),无论采取何种面向地块分类的策略,这些干扰像元都将增加分类的不确定性; ②虽然大多数地块数据常年不变,但由于农作物轮作与生产计划改变,仍有部分地块边界会发生变化。如果这部分地块数据更新不及时,可能出现一个地块种植多种农作物的情况。如何解决干扰像元与地块混合的问题,最大程度发挥地块数据在分类中的优势,亟需进一步研究。

3.3 遥感数据空间分辨率

一般来说,遥感数据的空间分辨率越高,其识别地物的能力越强,面向对象分类也大多针对高空间分辨率数据。但是,在实际开展农作物遥感识别工作中,农作物可分辨程度不完全决定于空间分辨率,而是和目标地块的形状、大小,以及它与周围地物亮度、结构的相对差异有关[59]。因此,不应一味追求高空间分辨率,而是在获得精确的地块边界后,分析空间分辨率对面向地块农作物遥感分类的影响,研究不同地块形态(大小、形状等)下分类精度与空间分辨率的关系,进而选择最优空间分辨率的遥感数据。

3.4 分类特征

目前农作物遥感分类特征选择较多地考虑了遥感数据的光谱特征、时相特征和空间特征等,没有充分研究从农作物自身具有的特征进行具有机理性的特征变量的构建和选择[51]。不同农作物种植特点、生理生化参数和冠层特征等差异特别明显,如果能将这些更具理论基础的特征(如地块形状、叶绿素含量、叶面积指数和株高等)应用于农作物遥感分类,将会大幅提高农作物遥感分类精度。因此,应该深入开展农作物遥感分类新型特征的挖掘与综合应用。

3.5 样本数量

在进行监督分类时,训练样本的数量对分类精度有较大影响,但是样本采集是一项费时费力的工作,通常情况下难以获得理想数量的分类样本。如何用较少的样本获得较高的精度是农作物遥感分类中值得思考的问题。在面向地块的农作物分类中,若采用先面向像元再面向地块分类的策略,则可以将点类型训练样本扩展至面,这样就大大增加了训练样本数量。另外,可以考虑不同分类器对训练样本的依赖度,在保证分类精度的同时选择对样本依赖度较低的分类器进行分类。

4 研究展望

随着遥感技术的快速发展,新型传感器不断涌现,尤其是高空间分辨率影像的出现,为农作物精细识别提供了更加丰富的信息。但是基于像元的高空间分辨率遥感分类往往面临光谱变异和光谱混合问题,面向地块的农作物遥感分类能够很好地解决以上问题。近年来,面向地块的农作物遥感分类取得了很大进展,但是仍存在很多难点和挑战,制约着分类精度和效率。未来应进一步开展面向地块的农作物遥感分类研究,提高农作物分类精度和效率,满足实际农业应用的需要。

1)应用于面向地块农作物遥感分类的数据应多元化。高空间分辨率数据有助于获取准确的地块边界信息,因而被广泛应用于面向地块的农作物遥感分类。但是高空间分辨率影像意味着有更多的信息需要处理,因此需要发展新的遥感信息处理技术。在发展新技术的同时,不妨考虑在获得准确的地块边界后,针对研究区地块特点利用中低空间分辨率遥感影像进行农作物识别,充分发挥中低空间分辨率数据幅宽大、重访周期短、处理简单等优势。在进行农作物精细识别时,应充分考虑遥感数据光谱分辨率、空间分辨率和时间分辨率的关系,必要时充分利用多源遥感数据实现农作物的精确提取。另外,地形、气象和各类专题信息等也可以作为辅助数据引入农作物分类中来,以提高农作物分类精度。

2)地块边界获取技术有待进一步发展。尽管未来越来越多的地块数据将实现共享,但部分地区在初次绘制地块边界时仍存在一些问题。在获取大范围地块边界数据时,矢量化方式精度较高,但耗费大量人力、时间; 影像分割虽然大大提高了效率,但其分割对象往往与实际地块不符。这些问题很大程度上影响了面向地块分类的实际应用。因此,应进一步研究影像分割技术,尽可能保证分割对象与地理实体的一致性,或者发展新的地块边界检测技术。

3)分类特征应进一步挖掘与综合应用。目前在面向地块的农作物遥感分类中,多使用传统的光谱特征、时相特征和空间特征,分类特征的挖掘与综合应用将成为以后遥感分类的重要内容。地块面积和形态等一定程度上反映了不同农作物的种植特点及差异,因此可以尝试使用地块的周长、面积和形状等特征进行分类。另外,结合农作物自身特点,构建新的具有农学、生物学和物理学意义的分类特征,例如反映农作物冠层特征的叶面积指数、反映农作物生理生化状况的叶绿素、激光雷达数据的高度信息以及无人机可获得的株距行距等。这些新的特征与传统特征变量可以同时应用于农作物遥感分类,提高分类精度的同时使其更具可解释性。

4)农作物遥感分类的运行化能力应进一步提升。目前国内利用遥感能够识别的农作物类型偏少,主要集中在小麦、玉米、水稻和大豆等主要农作物,而棉花、甘蔗、油菜和花生等其他农作物较少涉及,因此应该进一步挖掘遥感数据识别这些农作物的潜力,更好地满足不同用户对农作物识别的需求。农作物遥感分类的时效性也应进一步提高,农作物识别是其他一切工作的基础,只有及时准确地提取农作物空间分布,才能为农田管理打好基础。在实际农业应用中,应尽量简化遥感信息提取过程,以满足不同人群的需求,进一步扩大遥感在农业领域的应用。

参考文献

蒙继华, 吴炳方, 杜鑫 , .

遥感在精准农业中的应用进展及展望

[J]. 国土资源遥感, 2011,23(3):1-7.doi: 10.6046/gtzyyg.2011.03.01.

URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

<p>精准农业是现代农业的重要组成部分,它通过各种技术手段获取农田内不同单元小区农作物的生长环境信息,并由此实现整个生产过程的精细化、准确化的农业微观经营管理。由于遥感技术能在不同的电磁谱段内周期性地采集地表信息,因此随着遥感技术的发展,其在精准农业领域开始发挥越来越大的作用,并在指导农田灌溉、施肥、病虫害防治、杂草控制及收获等方面均已有很多成功的应用。为使人们对遥感在精准农业中的应用有一总体了解,在概述遥感技术在精准农业领域应用进展的基础上,对其研究现状进行了分析总结,还对其发展进行了展望,并指出了技术方法的改进、新数据的应用、多源数据整合、遥感数据与农学/作物模型的整合以及监测技术的系统化是促进遥感技术在精准农业中发挥更大作用的主要研究内容。</p>

Meng J H, Wu B F, Du X , et al.

A review and outlook of applying remote sensing to precision agriculture

[J]. Remote Sensing for Land and Resources, 2011,23(3):1-7.doi: 10.6046/gtzyyg.2011.03.01.

Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

赵春江 .

农业遥感研究与应用进展

[J]. 农业机械学报, 2014,45(12):277-293.

DOI:10.6041/j.issn.1000-1298.2014.12.041      URL     [本文引用: 2]

农业是遥感技术应用最重要和广泛的领域之一,本文回顾了遥感技术在国内外农业研究与应用中的进展,概括和总结了农田辐射传输机理及作物参量遥感反演、作物遥感分类与识别、农田养分遥感与变量施肥决策、作物产量与品质预测、农情遥感监测与预报、农业遥感监测空间决策支持系统6个主要研究与应用方面。在此基础上,针对农业遥感技术面临的问题与发展趋势,指出了农业遥感技术今后的重点发展方向。

Zhao C J .

Advances of research and application in remote sensing for agriculture

[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society for Agricultural Machinery, 2014,45(12):277-293.

[本文引用: 2]

陈水森, 柳钦火, 陈良富 , .

粮食作物播种面积遥感监测研究进展

[J]. 农业工程学报, 2005,21(6):166-171.

DOI:10.3321/j.issn:1002-6819.2005.06.037      URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

介绍了遥感监测粮食作物播种面积的理论和现实意义,回顾了国内外基于常规方法、线状框架采样、面积框架采样、光谱混合模型(spectral mixture model , SMA)等方法进行植被制图和进行粮食作物识别研究的现状和存在的问题, 并对基于波谱库的农作物播种面积监测提出了建议。

Chen S S, Liu Q H, Chen L F , et al.

Review of research advances in remote sensing monitoring of grain crop area

[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2005,21(6):166-171.

Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

宋茜, 周清波, 吴文斌 , .

农作物遥感识别中的多源数据融合研究进展

[J]. 中国农业科学, 2015,48(6):1122-1135.

DOI:10.3864/j.issn.0578-1752.2015.06.09      URL     [本文引用: 1]

农作物遥感识别是地理学和生态学研究的前沿和热点,多源数据在农作遥感识别中日益发挥重要作用。笔者从多源数据融合的角度,归纳了2000年后多源数据在农作物遥感识别中应用的总体概况,系统梳理并提炼了当前多源数据融合的主要融合技术和融合模式。围绕与多源数据融合和农作物遥感识别相关的关键词,在Google学术、ISI Web of Knowledge和中国知网中对2000—2014年间国内外发表的论文进行检索,并统计不同传感器的使用频率及结合方式。研究表明,以提高空间分辨率为目标的多源数据融合和以提高时间分辨率为目标的多源数据融合技术是当前的两种主要方式,可以在一定程度上实现时空尺度的扩展。前者的融合技...

Song Q, Zhou Q B, Wu W B , et al.

Recent progresses in research of integrating multi-source remote sensing data for crop mapping

[J]. Scientia Agricultura Sinica, 2015,48(6):1122-1135.

[本文引用: 1]

Atzberger C .

Advances in remote sensing of agriculture:Context description,existing operational monitoring systems and major information needs

[J]. Remote Sensing, 2013,5(2):949-981.

DOI:10.3390/rs5020949      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Wardlow B D, Egbert S L, Kastens J H .

Analysis of time-series MODIS 250 m vegetation index data for crop classification in the U.S. Central Great Plains

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2007,108(3):290-310.

DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2006.11.021      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The global environmental change research community requires improved and up-to-date land use/land cover (LULC) datasets at regional to global scales to support a variety of science and policy applications. Considerable strides have been made to improve large-area LULC datasets, but little emphasis has been placed on thematically detailed crop mapping, despite the considerable influence of management activities in the cropland sector on various environmental processes and the economy. Time-series MODIS 250 m Vegetation Index (VI) datasets hold considerable promise for large-area crop mapping in an agriculturally intensive region such as the U.S. Central Great Plains, given their global coverage, intermediate spatial resolution, high temporal resolution (16-day composite period), and cost-free status. However, the specific spectral emporal information contained in these data has yet to be thoroughly explored and their applicability for large-area crop-related LULC classification is relatively unknown. The objective of this research was to investigate the general applicability of the time-series MODIS 250 m Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI) and Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) datasets for crop-related LULC classification in this region. A combination of graphical and statistical analyses were performed on a 12-month time-series of MODIS EVI and NDVI data from more than 2000 cropped field sites across the U.S. state of Kansas. Both MODIS VI datasets were found to have sufficient spatial, spectral, and temporal resolutions to detect unique multi-temporal signatures for each of the region's major crop types (alfalfa, corn, sorghum, soybeans, and winter wheat) and management practices (double crop, fallow, and irrigation). Each crop's multi-temporal VI signature was consistent with its general phenological characteristics and most crop classes were spectrally separable at some point during the growing season. Regional intra-class VI signature variations were found for some crops across Kansas that reflected the state's climate and planting time differences. The multi-temporal EVI and NDVI data tracked similar seasonal responses for all crops and were highly correlated across the growing season. However, differences between EVI and NDVI responses were most pronounced during the senescence phase of the growing season.

Yu K, Wang Z, Sun L, et al.

Crop growth condition monitoring and analyzing in county scale by time series MODIS medium-resolution data

[C]//Second International Conference on Agro-Geoinformatics, 2013: 1-6.

[本文引用: 1]

韩衍欣, 蒙继华, 徐晋 .

基于NDVI与物候修正的大豆长势评价方法

[J]. 农业工程学报, 2017,33(2):177-182.

DOI:10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2017.02.024      URL     [本文引用: 1]

及时、准确的作物长势监测可以为宏观决策和农田生产提供作物生长信息,便于及时采取各种田间管理措施,达到科学管理和作物增产的目的。归一化植被指数(normalized difference vegetation index,NDVI)与植被的叶面积指数(leaf area index,LAI)和叶片叶绿素含量关系极为密切,可以用来评价作物的生长状况。为了降低主观因素及物候差异对大豆长势监测的影响,该研究以黑龙江红星农场主要农作物大豆为例,基于历史NDVI数据建立了该区域大豆长势评价的标准。利用NDVI时间序列拟合法提取大豆关键物候期,结合物候监测结果对大豆长势进行修正,最后利用41个地块的单产数据对长势评价结果进行了验证。物候修正前后长势与单产的一致性分别为58.5%、75.6%,容差为1个等级时分别为87.8%、95.1%,表明历史NDVI对大豆长势评价有一定参考意义,但简单同期对比不能完全反映大豆长势真实情况,物候修正可以进一步改善长势评价效果。研究可以为利用遥感进行大豆长势评价提供参考依据。

Han Y X, Meng J H, Xu J .

Soybean growth assessment method based on NDVI and phenological calibration

[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2017,33(2):177-182.

[本文引用: 1]

Islam A S, Bala S K .

Assessment of potato phenological characteristics using MODIS-derived NDVI and LAI information

[J]. GIScience and Remote Sensing, 2008,45(4):443-453.

DOI:10.2747/1548-1603.45.4.443      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Land use and land cover changes have as consequences several social, economic, and environmental impacts. The understanding of these changes allows a better planning of public policies in order to map and monitor areas more susceptible to environmental problems. This research presents an analysis of the land use and land cover changes of a watershed region located in the Brazilian Amazon, and an evaluation of their impacts on sediment yield. Land use/land cover maps for each of the analyzed time periods (1973, 1984, and 2005) were compiled using images obtained by MSS/Landsat-1, TM/Landsat-5, and the MODIS/Terra sensors. The sediment yield modeling was performed by dividing the watershed into homogeneous subregions. Each of the subregions received average attributes that were used as input parameters for the Universal Soil Loss Equation. The results revealed that up to 2005, around 40% of the study area was already deforested, replaced by agricultural activities. In some parts of the watershed these changes were responsible for an increase of up to 7 ton/ha in annual average sediment yield. This study was successful in providing an assessment of the magnitude and spatial distribution of the changes.

Cheng Z, Meng J, Wang Y .

Improving spring maize yield estimation at field scale by assimilating time-series HJ-1 CCD data into the WOFOST model using a new method with fast algorithms

[J]. Remote Sensing, 2016,8(4), 303.

DOI:10.3390/rs8040303      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Field crop yield prediction is crucial to grain storage, agricultural field management, and national agricultural decision-making. Currently, crop models are widely used for crop yield prediction. However, they are hampered by the uncertainty or similarity of input parameters when extrapolated to field scale. Data assimilation methods that combine crop models and remote sensing are the most effective methods for field yield estimation. In this study, the World Food Studies (WOFOST) model is used to simulate the growing process of spring maize. Common assimilation methods face some difficulties due to the scarce, constant, or similar nature of the input parameters. For example, yield spatial heterogeneity simulation, coexistence of common assimilation methods and the nutrient module, and time cost are relatively important limiting factors. To address the yield simulation problems at field scale, a simple yet effective method with fast algorithms is presented for assimilating the time-series HJ-1 A/B data into the WOFOST model in order to improve the spring maize yield simulation. First, the WOFOST model is calibrated and validated to obtain the precise mean yield. Second, the time-series leaf area index (LAI) is calculated from the HJ data using an empirical regression model. Third, some fast algorithms are developed to complete assimilation. Finally, several experiments are conducted in a large farmland (Hongxing) to evaluate the yield simulation results. In general, the results indicate that the proposed method reliably improves spring maize yield estimation in terms of spatial heterogeneity simulation ability and prediction accuracy without affecting the simulation efficiency.

覃志豪, 高懋芳, 秦晓敏 , .

农业旱灾监测中的地表温度遥感反演方法——以MODIS数据为例

[J]. 自然灾害学报, 2005,14(4):64-71.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1004-4574.2005.04.011      URL     [本文引用: 1]

以目前农业旱灾监测中应用较广泛的多波段MODIS卫星遥感数据为例,探讨农业旱灾遥感监测中所需要的地表温度反演问题,尤其是反演算法的选择、基本参数的估计和具体反演中的工作流程,为快速地进行农业旱灾监测中的水热遥感参数估计提供方法选择.虽然MODIS有8个热红外波段用来监测地表热量变化,但波段31和32特别适用于农业旱灾监测中所需要的地表温度遥感反演.因此,在算法上,我们将选择计算过程相对简便但反演精度又很高的两因素分裂窗算法.详细地讨论了如何快速地估计分裂窗算法中大气透过率和地表比辐射率这两个基本参数.从实际应用来看,本文所提出的方法能快速地用来反演我国农业旱灾监测中所需要的农田地表温度参数,并获得很好的反演结果.

Qin Z H, Gao M F, Qin X M , et al.

Methodology to retrieve land surface temperature from MODIS data for agricultural drought monitoring in China

[J]. Journal of Natural Disasters, 2005,14(4):64-71.

[本文引用: 1]

Wu B, Li Q .

Crop planting and type proportion method for crop acreage estimation of complex agricultural landscapes

[J]. International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation, 2012,16(1):101-112.

DOI:10.1016/j.jag.2011.12.006      URL     [本文引用: 1]

This study presents a crop planting and type proportion (CPTP) method for crop acreage estimation of complex and diverse agricultural landscapes. CPTP has three major components: (1) Crop planting proportion (CPP), estimated with wide-swath satellite remote sensing data to completely cover the monitoring area by segmenting cropped and non-cropped areas through unsupervised classification. (2) Crop type proportion (CTP), estimated by transect sampling and a special GPS-Video-GIS instrument (GVG) and a visual interpretation of crop type proportion in collected pictures for different strata. (3) Multiplication of CPP and CTP with arable land area at the strata level, summed to the province and national level. Validation has been done with in situ data for different agricultural landscapes over China. Both CPP estimation with remote sensing data and CTP estimation through ground survey have a high accuracy with average relative error (RE) and root mean square error (RMSE) equal to 1.42% and 1.67% for CPP and to 2.63% and 2.25% for CTP. The RE for crop acreage estimation equals to 4.09%. The CPTP method thus has a high accuracy, yields timely information at low costs, and is robust and provides objective results. The study concludes that the CPTP method can be used for large area crop acreage estimation of complex agriculture landscapes.

刘庆生, 黄翀, 刘高焕 , .

基于关键期HJ卫星数据提取无棣县作物种植面积

[J]. 中国农学通报, 2014,30(26):284-290.

DOI:10.11924/j.issn.1000-6850.2013-3313      URL     [本文引用: 1]

To explore the feasibility of quickly extracting planting area using HJ satellite CCD data acquired at the main crop key growth periods, a quick and easy crop planting area extraction method was presented. The author took Wudi County of Shandong Province as a study area, 3 HJ remote sensing images acquired at the main crop key growth periods were selected based on the main crop cultivation technique calendar. Through the EVI time-series data analysis and regions of interesting (ROI) creations, the support vector machine (SVM) was used for extracting the main crop planting area. The results showed that: the EVI data of the crop key growth periods in combination with the SVM method could more accurately estimate the winter wheat, corn and cotton planting area of Wudi County, and overall accuracy of total planting area extraction and spatial distribution location was more than 93% and 75% respectively. Through using the remote sensing data acquired at a crop key growth period, time and labor for remote sensing data processing was reduced greatly, and it was easy to visualize the choice of ROI. Only used SVM could guarantee the regional crop planting area extraction accuracy, which greatly simplified the operation process and provided a reference for other regions to use HJ satellite data to extract crop planting area.

Liu Q S, Huang C, Liu G H , et al.

Planting area extraction of a crop key growth period in Wudi County based on HJ satellite data

[J]. Chinese Agricultural Science Bulletin, 2014,30(26):284-290.

[本文引用: 1]

王立辉, 黄进良, 孙俊英 .

基于SVM的环境减灾卫星HJ-1B影像作物分类识别研究

[J]. 世界科技研究与发展, 2009,31(6):1029-1032.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1006-6055.2009.06.014      URL     [本文引用: 1]

环境减灾卫星作为我国自主研制 发射的环境与灾害监测预报卫星,要发挥它的作用就是要更好的使用其数据源。支持向量机(Support Vector Machine,SVM)是一种卓越的分类方法,本文通过SVM方法对环境减灾卫星HJ-1B星CCD影像数据进行作物分类识别实验并将结果与最大似然法 分类结果进行比较。结果表明:利用SVM方法进行遥感图像分类,精度优于传统的最大似然法分类精度;Hj-1 A/1B星CCD数据对于农作物具有较好的指示效果,可应用于作物识别等农业领域。

Wang L H, Huang J L, Sun J Y .

Study of crop classification by support vector machine on HJ-1B image

[J]. World Sci-Tech R and D, 2009,31(6):1029-1032.

[本文引用: 1]

Lu D, Weng Q .

A survey of image classification methods and techniques for improving classification performance

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2007,28(5):823-870.

DOI:10.1080/01431160600746456      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Image classification is a complex process that may be affected by many factors. This paper examines current practices, problems, and prospects of image classification. The emphasis is placed on the summarization of major advanced classification approaches and the techniques used for improving classification accuracy. In addition, some important issues affecting classification performance are discussed. This literature review suggests that designing a suitable image‐processing procedure is a prerequisite for a successful classification of remotely sensed data into a thematic map. Effective use of multiple features of remotely sensed data and the selection of a suitable classification method are especially significant for improving classification accuracy. Non‐parametric classifiers such as neural network, decision tree classifier, and knowledge‐based classification have increasingly become important approaches for multisource data classification. Integration of remote sensing, geographical information systems (GIS), and expert system emerges as a new research frontier. More research, however, is needed to identify and reduce uncertainties in the image‐processing chain to improve classification accuracy.

Blaes X, Holecz F ,Leeuwen H J C V ,et al.

Regional crop monitoring and discrimination based on simulated ENVISAT ASAR wide swath mode images

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2007,28(2):371-393.

DOI:10.1080/01431160600735608      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The current paper investigates the potential contribution of ENVISAT wide swath (WS) images for discrimination and monitoring of crops at a regional scale. The study was based on synthetic aperture radar (SAR) images acquired throughout an entire growing season. Advanced synthetic aperture radar sensor (ASAR) images in both narrow swath (NS) and WS modes were simulated based on 15 European Remote Sensing (ERS) satellite images recorded over Belgium. Unlike ‘real’ ASAR imagery, this exercise provided a consistent data set (i.e. same incidence angle, same acquisition date, same acquisition hour) to study the impact of spatial resolution on the SAR signal information content. A quantitative approach using 787 parcels of medium field size and various data combinations assessed monitoring and discrimination capabilities for six crop types: wheat, barley, grasses, sugar beet, maize and potato. The spatial resolution impact of the ASAR sensor was discussed with respect to the field size by comparing the results obtained from NS (3002m) and WS (15002m) mode images. WS temporal profiles were able to discriminate the various crops of interest and were representative of the crop development observed in the region. Furthermore, parcel‐based unsupervised classifications successfully discriminated between grass, wheat, barley and other crops of large parcels (success rate of 83%). Dedicated interpretation schemes were developed in order to discriminate between cereal crops.

Mariotto I, Thenkabail P S, Huete A , et al.

Hyperspectral versus,multispectral crop-productivity modeling and type discrimination for the HyspIRI mission

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2013,139(4):291-305.

DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2013.08.002      URL     [本文引用: 1]

61Narrowbands explained ~25% greater variability than broadbands in crop modeling.61Narrowbands provided ~20% greater accuracies than broadbands in crop discrimination.613–7 narrowbands explained over 90% variability in crop models.61Highly informative and redundant narrowbands helped overcome Hughes phenomenon.6129 key Hyperion hyperspectral narrowband centers in crop studies were identified.

Turker M, Ozdarici A .

Field-based crop classification using SP-OT4,SPOT5,IKONOS and QuickBird imagery for agricultural areas:A comparison study

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2011,32(24):9735-9768.

DOI:10.1080/01431161.2011.576710      URL     [本文引用: 2]

A comparison of agricultural crop maps from independent field-based classifications of the Satellite Pour l'Observation de la Terre (SPOT) 4 multispectral (XS), SPOT5 XS, IKONOS XS, QuickBird XS and QuickBird pan-sharpened (PS) images is presented. An agricultural area within the north-west section of Turkey was analysed for field-based crop identification. The SPOT4 XS, SPOT5 XS, IKONOS XS and QuickBird images were collected in similar climatic conditions during July and August 2004. The classification of each image was carried out separately on a per-field basis on all bands and the coincident bands that are green, red and near-infrared (NIR). To examine the effect of filtering on field-based classification, the images were each filtered using the 365×653, 565×655, 765×657 and 965×659 mean filter and the filtered bands were also classified on per-field basis. For the unfiltered images, IKONOS XS provided the highest overall accuracies of 88.9% and 88.1% for the all-bands and the coincident bands classifications, respectively. On average, IKONOS XS performed slightly better than QuickBird XS and QuickBird PS, while it outperformed SPOT4 XS and SPOT5 XS. The use of filtered images in field-based classification reduced the accuracies for SPOT4 XS, SPOT5 XS, IKONOS XS and QuickBird XS. The results of this study indicate that smoothing images prior to classification does not improve the accuracies for the field-based classification. On the contrary, the accuracies for the filtered QuickBird PS images indicated a slight improvement. On the whole, both IKONOS and QuickBird images produced quite promising results for field-based crop mapping, yielding overall accuracies above 83%.

顾晓鹤, 潘耀忠, 何馨 , .

以地块分类为核心的冬小麦种植面积遥感估算

[J]. 遥感学报, 2010,14(4):789-805.

DOI:10.3724/SP.J.1011.2010.01138      URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 4]

以提高冬小麦种植面积估算精度为目标,选取种植结构复杂的都市农业区,采用QuickBird影像数字化农田地块边界,以多时相TM影像为核心数据源,以地块为基本分类单元,进行不同特征向量组合、不同分类器的冬小麦地块分类方法研究,并对比分析了基于地块分类和基于像元分类的冬小麦种植面积估算精度.研究结果表明,基于地块分类的冬小麦种植面积估算方法的总量精度和位置精度均高于像元分类;植被指数和纹理信息的引入有助于进一步提高地块分类精度;支持向量机与最大似然均能得到高达97%的总量精度和90%的位置精度,支持向量机地块分类所需的训练样本量远低于最大似然,因此支持向量机更加适合于冬小麦地块分类;冬小麦错分与漏分情况大多发生在细碎地块,其面积总量较小,而大地块错分和漏分较少,因此相对于像元分类,地块分类能在整个区域能得到较高的冬小麦位置精度和总量精度.

Gu X H, Pan Y Z, He X , et al.

Measurement of sown area of winter wheat based on per-field classification and remote sensing imagery

[J]. Journal of Remote Sensing, 2010,14(4):789-805.

Magsci     [本文引用: 4]

张雨果, 王飞, 孙文义 , .

基于面向对象的SPOT卫星影像梯田信息提取研究

[J]. 水土保持研究, 2016,23(6):345-351.

URL     [本文引用: 1]

梯田信息准确和快速提取是区域水土保持动态监测和评价的核心技术之一,运用遥感技术进行地物信息提取是一种有效手段。该研究以燕沟流域为研究区,采用高分辨率的SPOT5遥感影像数据,基于面向对象分类技术,通过影像分割构建影像对象,在分析影像对象的光谱特征、纹理特征和空间特征的基础上,建立了梯田信息的遥感提取规则,实现了梯田的自动提取。最后用手工勾绘结果对梯田的遥感提取结果进行精度评价,从田块边界的吻合度评价位置精度,并通过比较该结果与人工目视解译结果进行面积精度评价。结果表明,基于面向对象分类的遥感方法可以较好地从原始影像中提取复杂地貌区梯田的位置信息,面积提取正确率达到78.38%,该方法可为黄土高原地区梯田信息遥感提取提供借鉴。

Zhang Y G, Wang F, Sun W Y , et al.

Terrace information extraction from SPOT remote sensing image based on object-oriented classification method

[J]. Research of Soil and Water Conservation, 2016,23(6):345-351.

[本文引用: 1]

Smith G M, Fuller R M .

An integrated approach to land cover classification:An example in the island of Jersey

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2001,22(16):3123-3142.

DOI:10.1080/01431160152558288      URL     [本文引用: 1]

A land cover map of Jersey was created using remotely sensed images recorded by satellite. This map brought together a range of disparate techniques, developed in isolation and mostly applied experimentally, integrating multisensor, multitemporal, enhanced spatial resolution data within an object-oriented integrated Geographical Information System (GIS) for an applications-driven, operational programme. It was developed under the Classification of Environment with Vector- and Raster-Mapping (CLEVER-Mapping) project: this improved approach to operational land cover mapping used information on the subdivision of the landscape into land parcels to help classify remotely sensed images on a per-parcel basis. The object-oriented approach allowed the use of remotely sensed information which relates directly to ground features, and the application of improved knowledge-based corrections using a range of external data. Unlike a conventional map, the parcel-based approach produced a GIS database containing classified land parcels which could also be used as a storage framework and analysis tool for other datasets in later analyses. The GIS recorded 21 land cover types. Validation against reference land parcel data gave a correspondence of between 85% and 95% depending on the level of class aggregation.

潘瑜春, 黄兴荣, 马景宇 , .

面向精准农业的农田地块更新地理信息系统

[J].农机化研究, 2006(8):77-81.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-188X.2006.08.027      URL     [本文引用: 1]

农田地块是农田地理要素的典型要素。为此,分析了农田地块变更的数据源及其更新形式,并提出了农田地块更新模型,以便满足不同数据源的地块更新实现的需要,最后依据农田地块更新模型设计了面向精准农业应用的农田地块更新地理信息系统的体系结构、数据库结构及其功能结构。

Pan Y C, Huang X R, Ma J Y , et al.

Field parcel information collection and update system forprecision agriculture

[J].Journal of Agricultural Mechanization Research, 2006(8):77-81.

[本文引用: 1]

李琴, 李大胜, 陈风波 .

地块特征对农业机械服务利用的影响分析——基于南方五省稻农的实证研究

[J].农业经济问题, 2017(7):43-52.

URL     [本文引用: 1]

本文基于南方五省稻农地块的微观数据,利用固定效应模型分析了地块特征对稻农农业机械利用的影响。地块特征通过4个方面影响农户农机利用:地块零碎化、土壤质量、基础设施便利性、地块来源。研究表明,地块面积越大,稻农越容易采用农机作业。土壤质量越差,越不利于稻农采用农机进行收割。相对于其他因素,地块基础设施对稻农是否采用农业机械生产的影响最大。如果地块灌溉条件不好或机耕路不便使得机器难以抵达田间,则农户使用机器耕整和收割的概率分别下降13.1和41.6个百分点。如果地块是从市场租入,则农户采用农机作业的概率增加。

Li Q, Li D S, Chen F B .

Analysis of the effect of plot characteristics on the utilization of agricultural machinery:Based on the rice plots data of south China

[J].Issues in Agricultural Economy, 2017(7):43-52.

[本文引用: 1]

Turker M, Arikan M .

Sequential masking classification of multi-temporal Landsat7 ETM+ images for field-based crop mapping in Karacabey,Turkey

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2005,26(17):3813-3830.

DOI:10.1080/01431160500166391      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Three Landsat7 ETM+ images acquired in May, July and August during the 2000 crop growing season were used for field‐based mapping of summer crops in Karacabey, Turkey. First, the classification of each image date was performed on a standard per pixel basis. The results of per pixel classification were integrated with digital agricultural field boundaries and a crop type was determined for each field based on the modal class calculated within the field. The classification accuracy was computed by comparing the reference data, field‐by‐field, to each classified image. The individual crop accuracies were examined on each classified data and those crops whose accuracy exceeds a preset threshold level were determined. A sequential masking classification procedure was then performed using the three image dates, excluding after each classification the class properly classified. The final classified data were analysed on a field basis to assign each field a class label. An immediate update of the database was provided by directly entering the results of the analysis into the database. The sequential masking procedure for field‐based crop mapping improved the overall accuracies of the classifications of the July and August images alone by more than 10%.

范磊, 程永政, 王来刚 , .

基于多尺度分割的面向对象分类方法提取冬小麦种植面积

[J]. 中国农业资源与区划, 2010,31(6):44-51.

DOI:10.7621/cjarrp.1005-9121.20100610      URL     [本文引用: 1]

应用面向对象方法,对遥感图像进行多尺度分割,即首先进行大尺度分割,结合NDVI提取植被信息,将图像分为植被和非植被;然后在植被信息类内再进行小尺度分割,利用NDVI并融入几何特征进一步提取冬小麦种植面积及空间分布.在遥感分类的基础上,将线性数据按宽度缓冲,从分类结果中扣除.将扣除结果与地面样方实测数据对比分析.结果表明,监测结果减轻了传统分类方法的椒盐效应,监测结果与验证样方数据比较精度为94.06%.

Fan L, Cheng Y Z, Wang L G , et al.

Estimation of winter wheat planting area using object-oriented method based on multi-scale segmentation

[J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planting, 2010,31(6):44-51.

[本文引用: 1]

Zhang X, Du S .

Learning selfhood scales for urban land cover mapping with very-high-resolution satellite images

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2016,178:172-190.

DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2016.03.015      URL     [本文引用: 1]

61The proposed selfhood scales can measure local contexts of pixels.61Self-adaptive segmentation with selfhood scales outperforms multiresolution segmentation.61The proposed multi-level classifier excels in using multiscale features.61Selfhood scales can improve both per-pixel and object-based classifications.61The proposed methods produce urban land cover maps with larger accuracy.

Long J A, Lawrence R L, Greenwood M C , et al.

Object-oriented crop classification using multitemporal ETM+ SLC-off imagery and random forest

[J]. GIScience and Remote Sensing, 2013,50(4):418-436.

DOI:10.1080/15481603.2013.817150      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The utility of Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+) has been diminished since the 2003 scan-line corrector (SLC) failure. Uncorrected images have data gaps of approximately 22% and gap-filling schemes have been developed to improve their usability. We present a method to classify a northeast Montana agricultural landscape using ETM+ SLC-off imagery without gap-filling. We use multitemporal data analysis and employ an object-oriented approach to define objects, agricultural fields, with cadastral data. This approach was assessed by comparison to a pixel-based approach. Results indicate that an ETM+ SLC-off image can be classified with better than 85% overall accuracy without gap-filling.

Peña-Barragán J M, Ngugi M K, Plant R E , et al.

Object-based crop identification using multiple vegetation indices,textural features and crop phenology

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2011,115(6):1301-1316.

DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2011.01.009      URL     [本文引用: 2]

78 Decision tree modeling is suitable to identify crops at different field conditions. 78 Consideration of intra-class variations is required to improve classifications. 78 Textural features improve discrimination among heterogeneous permanent crops. 78 Information from NIR and SWIR bands is needed for detailed crop identification. 78 Crop identification requires the study of field status in distinct growing seasons.

Peña J, Gutiérrez P, Hervásmartínez C , et al.

Object-based image classification of summer crops with machine learning methods

[J]. Remote Sensing, 2014,6(6):5019-5041.

DOI:10.3390/rs6065019      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The strategic management of agricultural lands involves crop field monitoring each year. Crop discrimination via remote sensing is a complex task, especially if different crops have a similar spectral response and cropping pattern. In such cases, crop identification could be improved by combining object-based image analysis and advanced machine learning methods. In this investigation, we evaluated the C4.5 decision tree, logistic regression (LR), support vector machine (SVM) and multilayer perceptron (MLP) neural network methods, both as single classifiers and combined in a hierarchical classification, for the mapping of nine major summer crops (both woody and herbaceous) from ASTER satellite images captured in two different dates. Each method was built with different combinations of spectral and textural features obtained after the segmentation of the remote images in an object-based framework. As single classifiers, MLP and SVM obtained maximum overall accuracy of 88%, slightly higher than LR (86%) and notably higher than C4.5 (79%). The SVM+SVM classifier (best method) improved these results to 89%. In most cases, the hierarchical classifiers considerably increased the accuracy of the most poorly classified class (minimum sensitivity). The SVM+SVM method offered a significant improvement in classification accuracy for all of the studied crops compared to the conventional decision tree classifier, ranging between 4% for safflower and 29% for corn, which suggests the application of object-based image analysis and advanced machine learning methods in complex crop classification tasks.

Stumpf A, Kerle N .

Object-oriented mapping of landslides using random forests

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2011,115(10):2564-2577.

DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2011.05.013      URL     [本文引用: 1]

78 Image segmentation and the Random Forest framework are combined for landslide mapping from different VHR remote sensing images. 78 Newly introduced object features and feature selection enhance the classification accuracy. 78 A scheme to account for unbalanced error rates is proposed and tested. 78 The algorithm performs robustly with different types of input datasets. 78 Employing 20% of the data for training, mapping accuracies between 73% and 87% were achieved.

Silveira M, Nascimento J C, Marques J S , et al.

Comparison of segmentation methods for melanoma diagnosis in dermoscopy images

[J]. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing, 2009,3(1):35-45.

DOI:10.1109/JSTSP.2008.2011119      URL     [本文引用: 1]

In this paper, we propose and evaluate six methods for the segmentation of skin lesions in dermoscopic images. This set includes some state of the art techniques which have been successfully used in many medical imaging problems (gradient vector flow (GVF) and the level set method of Chan et al.[(C-LS)]. It also includes a set of methods developed by the authors which were tailored to this particular application (adaptive thresholding (AT), adaptive snake (AS), EM level set (EM-LS), and fuzzy-based split-and-merge algorithm (FBSM)]. The segmentation methods were applied to 100 dermoscopic images and evaluated with four different metrics, using the segmentation result obtained by an experienced dermatologist as the ground truth. The best results were obtained by the AS and EM-LS methods, which are semi-supervised methods. The best fully automatic method was FBSM, with results only slightly worse than AS and EM-LS.

Meinel G, Neubert M .

A comparison of segmentation programs for high resolution remote sensing data

[J]. International Archives of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing XXXV, 2004: 1097-1105.

[本文引用: 1]

Zhou W, Huang G, Cadenasso M L .

Does spatial configuration matter? Understanding the effects of land cover pattern on land surface temperature in urban landscapes

[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2011,102(1):54-63.

DOI:10.1016/j.landurbplan.2011.03.009      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The effects of land cover composition on land surface temperature (LST) have been extensively documented. Few studies, however, have examined the effects of land cover configuration. This paper investigates the effects of both the composition and configuration of land cover features on LST in Baltimore, MD, USA, using correlation analyses and multiple linear regressions. Landsat ETM + image data were used to estimate LST. The composition and configuration of land cover features were measured by a series of landscape metrics, which were calculated based on a high-resolution land cover map with an overall accuracy of 92.3%. We found that the composition of land cover features is more important in determining LST than their configuration. The land cover feature that most significantly affects the magnitude of LST is the percent cover of buildings. In contrast, percent cover of woody vegetation is the most important factor mitigating UHI effects. However, the configuration of land cover features also matters. Holding composition constant, LST can be significantly increased or decreased by different spatial arrangements of land cover features. These results suggest that the impact of urbanization on UHI can be mitigated not only by balancing the relative amounts of various land cover features, but also by optimizing their spatial configuration. This research expands our scientific understanding of the effects of land cover pattern on UHI by explicitly quantifying the effects of configuration. In addition, it may provide important insights for urban planners and natural resources managers on mitigating the impact of urban development on UHI.

Wit A J W D, Clevers J G P W .

Efficiency and accuracy of per-field classification for operational crop mapping

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2004,25(20):4091-4112.

DOI:10.1080/01431160310001619580      URL     [本文引用: 3]

A crop map of The Netherlands was created using a methodology that integrates multi-temporal and multi-sensor satellite imagery, statistical data on crop area and parcel boundaries from a 165:651065000 digital topographic map. In the first phase a crop field database was created by extracting static parcel boundaries from the digital topographic map and by adding dynamic crop boundaries using on-screen digitizing. In the next phase the crop type was determined from the spectral and phenological properties of each field. The resulting crop map has an accuracy larger than 80% for most individual crops and an overall accuracy of 90%. By comparing cost and man-hours it was demonstrated that per-field classification is more efficient than per-pixel classification and decreased the effort for classification from 1500 to 500 man-hours, but the effort for creating the crop field database was estimated at 2300 man-hours. The use of image segmentation techniques for deriving the crop field database was discussed. It was concluded that image segmentation cannot replace the use of a large-scale topographic map but, in the future, image segmentation may be used to map the dynamic crop boundaries within the topographic parcels.

苏春梅, 曹殿才, 金成范 .

地理国情普查数据与国土二调数据的对比分析

[J].测绘与空间地理信息, 2015(9):100-102.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-5867.2015.09.033      URL     [本文引用: 1]

第一次地理国情普查在全国范围内如火如荼地进行着,其数据的科学性、准确性和实用性一直受到相关行业的关注。本文对某市的地理国情普查成果数据与国土二调成果数据进行了对比分析,验证了地理国情普查数据的科学性和有效性,为下一步地理国情普查中数据时点核准提供了参考意见。

Su C M, Cao D C, Jin C F .

Study on comparative analysis of the data between the first geographical conditions census and the second national land cover census

[J].Geomatics and Spatial Information Technology, 2015(9):100-102.

[本文引用: 1]

陈俊勇 .

关于地理国情普查的思考

[J].地理空间信息, 2014(2):1-3.

DOI:10.11709/j.issn.1672-4623.2014.02.001      URL     [本文引用: 1]

地理国情主要是指地表自然和人文地理要素的空间分布、特征及其相互关系,是基本国情的重要组成部分,是重要的基本国情。全国地理国情普查为中国经济发展的科学规划、科学布局、科学发展提供了重要的基础信息。全国地理国情普查应从全局和战略的高度开展,需采用多种技术和手段采集、制作覆盖全国的、内容丰富的、客观真实的、准确权威的地理国情数据库,是对测绘地理信息部门的全面检验,也是推动测绘地理信息事业转型升级的一次重大机遇。

Chen J Y .

Reflections on the national geographic conditions census

[J].Geospatial Information, 2014(2):1-3.

[本文引用: 1]

吴琼 .

浅谈地理国情普查成果的应用

[J].测绘与空间地理信息, 2015(10):106-108.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-5867.2015.10.034      URL     [本文引用: 1]

地理国情普查是地理国情监测的首要任务,其成果作为地理国情本底数据,可为我国经济建设和社会发展提供科学的空间依据。本文在简要介绍地理国情普查背景和成果内容的基础上,阐述了地理国情普查成果在宏观决策、减灾防灾、生态文明建设等领域的应用构想。

Wu Q .

Application of the result of general survey of national geographic condition

[J].Geomatics and Spatial Information Technology, 2015(10):106-108.

[本文引用: 1]

张亚亚 .

基于GF-1遥感影像的农作物面积测量方法研究

[D]. 长春:吉林大学, 2017.

[本文引用: 1]

Zhang Y Y .

Research on the Method of Crop Area Measurement Based on GF-1 Remote Sensed Data

[D]. Changchun:Jilin University, 2017.

[本文引用: 1]

张水华 .

3S技术在农村集体土地确权中的应用

[J].测绘与空间地理信息, 2014(2):148-150.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-5867.2014.02.043      URL     [本文引用: 1]

以恩平市农村集体土地所有权登记发证项目为例,讨论了3S技术在农村集体土地确权中的应用。文章介绍了3S技术在农村土地确权中技术路线,结合项目特点,从调查底图制作、界址点测量、数据库管理等方面阐述了3S技术具体应用,为土地确权工作提供了强有力的工具,大大提高了作业效率;总结了3S技术在土地确权工作中应该注意的问题,以及未来3S技术在土地类项目中的发展趋势。

Zhang S H .

3S technology in the application of rural collective land counterpoising truly

[J].Geomatics and Spatial Information Technology, 2014(2):148-150.

[本文引用: 1]

Derenyi E.

A small crop information system

[C]//Proceedings of Remote Sensing for Natural Resources, 1979: 78-87.

[本文引用: 1]

Conrad C, Fritsch S, Zeidler J , et al.

Per-field irrigated crop classification in arid central asia using SPOT and ASTER data

[J]. Remote Sensing, 2010,2(4):1035-1056.

DOI:10.3390/rs2041035      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The overarching goal of this research was to explore accurate methods of mapping irrigated crops, where digital cadastre information is unavailable: (a) Boundary separation by object-oriented image segmentation using very high spatial resolution (2.5 5 m) data was followed by (b) identification of crops and crop rotations by means of phenology, tasselled cap, and rule-based classification using high resolution (15 30 m) bi-temporal data. The extensive irrigated cotton production system of the Khorezm province in Uzbekistan, Central Asia, was selected as a study region. Image segmentation was carried out on pan-sharpened SPOT data. Varying combinations of segmentation parameters (shape, compactness, and color) were tested for optimized boundary separation. The resulting geometry was validated against polygons digitized from the data and cadastre maps, analysing similarity (size, shape) and congruence. The parameters shape and compactness were decisive for segmentation accuracy. Differences between crop phenologies were analyzed at field level using bi-temporal ASTER data. A rule set based on the tasselled cap indices greenness and brightness allowed for classifying crop rotations of cotton, winter-wheat and rice, resulting in an overall accuracy of 80 %. The proposed field-based crop classification method can be an important tool for use in water demand estimations, crop yield simulations, or economic models in agricultural systems similar to Khorezm.

Löw F, Michel U, Dech S , et al.

Impact of feature selection on the accuracy and spatial uncertainty of per-field crop classification using support vector machines

[J]. ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2013,85(6):102-119.

DOI:10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2013.08.007      URL     [本文引用: 4]

Crop mapping is one major component of agricultural resource monitoring using remote sensing. Yield or water demand modeling requires that both, the total surface that is cultivated and the accurate distribution of crops, respectively is known. Map quality is crucial and influences the model outputs. Although the use of multi-spectral time series data in crop mapping has been acknowledged, the potentially high dimensionality of the input data remains an issue. In this study Support Vector Machines (SVM) are used for crop classification in irrigated landscapes at the object-level. Input to the classifications is 71 multi-seasonal spectral and geostatistical features computed from RapidEye time series. The random forest (RF) feature importance score was used to select a subset of features that achieved optimal accuracies. The relationship between the hard result accuracy and the soft output from the SVM is investigated by employing two measures of uncertainty, the maximum a posteriori probability and the alpha quadratic entropy. Specifically the effect of feature selection on map uncertainty is investigated by looking at the soft outputs of the SVM, in addition to classical accuracy metrics. Overall the SVMs applied to the reduced feature subspaces that were composed of the most informative multi-seasonal features led to a clear increase in classification accuracy up to 4.3%, and to a significant decline in thematic uncertainty. SVM was shown to be affected by feature space size and could benefit from RF-based feature selection. Uncertainty measures from SVM are an informative source of information on the spatial distribution of error in the crop maps.

Blaes X, Vanhalle L, Defourny P .

Efficiency of crop identification based on optical and SAR image time series

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2005,96(3):352-365.

DOI:10.1016/j.rse.2005.03.010      URL     [本文引用: 1]

This paper assessed the use of optical and SAR imagery for crop identification in an operational context with a particular emphasis on actual crop diversity and information delivery time. Fifteen ERS and Radarsat and 3 optical images were used to discriminate agricultural crop types based on dedicated per-parcel classification and photo interpretation schemes. For crop area control, the efficiency concept was introduced as a complementary indicator of classification performance. A set of 6571 parcels were classified into 39 crop types from various combinations of images. The efficiency computed from an independent set of 899 parcels peaked based on a combination of optical images and 3 to 5 SAR images. Moreover, the delivery time of the relevant information was improved when SAR data was included. The hierarchical classification strategy based on nested classifications also improved the operational crop control system for all image combinations. Finally, this research documented the respective contributions of optical and SAR time series for any control system of agricultural land.

Kussul N, Lemoine G, Gallego F J , et al.

Parcel-based crop classification in Ukraine using Landsat-8 data and Sentinel-1A data

[J]. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Applied Earth Observations and Remote Sensing, 2017,9(6):2500-2508.

DOI:10.1109/JSTARS.2016.2560141      URL     [本文引用: 2]

For many applied problems in agricultural monitoring and food security, it is important to provide reliable crop classification maps. Satellite imagery is extremely valuable source of data to provide crop maps in a timely way at moderate and high spatial resolution. Information on parcel boundaries that takes into account the spatial context may improve the quality of maps compared to pixel-based classification approaches. In general, parcels may contain several plots with different crops and such situations should be taken into account when using parcel boundaries. In this paper, we aim to compare pixel-based and parcel-based approaches to crop classification from multitemporal optical (Landsat-8) and synthetic-aperture radar (SAR) Sentinel-1 imagery. For this, we propose a parcel-based approach that involves a pixel-based classification map and specifically designed rules to account for several plots within parcel. The study is carried out for the Joint Experiment of Crop Assessment and Monitoring test site in Ukraine covering the Kyiv oblast (North of Ukraine) in 2013-2015, and the Odessa oblast (South of Ukraine) in 2014-2015. We found that pixel-based overall classification accuracy can be increased from 85.32% to 89.40% when using parcel boundaries. Among tested parcel-based approaches, the one that relied on pixel-based classification map and a procedure to select multiple plots within the parcel yielded the best performance.

Kuenzer C, Knauer K .

Remote sensing of rice crop areas:A review

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2013,34(6):2101-2139.

DOI:10.1080/01431161.2012.738946      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Rice means life for millions of people and it is planted in many regions of the world. It primarily grows in the major river deltas of Asia and Southeast Asia, such as the Mekong Delta, known as the Rice Bowl of Vietnam, the second-largest rice-producing nation on Earth. However, Latin America, the USA, and Australia have extensive rice-growing regions. In addition, rice is the most rapidly growing source of food in Africa. Rice is therefore of significant importance to food security in an increasing number of low-income food-deficit countries. This review article gives a complementary overview of how remote sensing can support the assessment of paddy rice cultivation worldwide. This article presents and discusses methods for rice mapping and monitoring, differentiating between the results achievable using different sensors of various spectral characteristics and spatial resolution. The remote sensing of rice-growing areas can not only contribute to the precise mapping of rice areas and the assessment of the dynamics in rice-growing regions, but can also contribute to harvest prediction modelling, the analyses of plant diseases, the assessment of rice-based greenhouse gas (methane) emission due to vegetation submersion, the investigation of erosion-control-adapted agricultural systems, and the assessment of ecosystem services in rice-growing areas.

刘亮, 姜小光, 李显彬 , .

利用高光谱遥感数据进行农作物分类方法研究

[J]. 中国科学院大学学报, 2006,23(4):484-488.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-1175.2006.04.008      URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

本文以北京顺义区为研究区,研究、探讨利用高光谱遥感数据,通过逐级分层分类方法进行农作物信息提取与挖掘的基本思路和步骤。该方法面向应用目标,将复杂的信息提取过程分为相对简单的子过程,每个子过程根据拟提取的目标不同而选择不同特征参数和信息提取方法,从而实现有效地利用高光谱数据丰富的信息,提高了信息提取的精度目的。

Liu L, Jiang X G, Li X B , et al.

Study on classification of agricultural crop by hyperspectral remote sensing data

[J]. Journal of the Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2006,23(4):484-488.

Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

刘佳, 王利民, 滕飞 , .

RapidEye卫星红边波段对农作物面积提取精度的影响

[J]. 农业工程学报, 2016,32(13):140-148.

DOI:10.11975/j.issn.1002-6819.2016.13.020      URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

在传统的可见光与红外波段基础上增加红边波段(690~730 nm),是当前高分辨卫星传感器研制的明显趋势。德国RapidEye卫星携带有红边波段传感器,该文基于黑龙江省北安市东胜乡2014年7月27日的RapidEye遥感数据,采用监督分类的方法,通过计算有红边参与条件下、无红边参与条件下,玉米、大豆及其他3种地物类型的可分性测度、分类精度及景观破碎度等指标,比较分析了2种波段组合方式下的红边波段对农作物面积提取精度的影响。其中,监督分类的训练样本是以覆盖研究区的2 km×2 km格网为基本单元,在玉米和大豆面积比例等概率原则下,选取了10个网格作为训练样本,样方内作物的识别采用目视解译的方式完成。精度验证是采用覆盖研究区的农作物面积本底调查结果评价的,本底调查数据是在5 m空间分辨率Rapideye数据初步分类基础上,根据多时相Landsat8/OLI(Operational Land Imager)数据季节变化规律,结合地面调查,采用目视修正的方法完成。结果表明,有红边参与的玉米、大豆和其他3种地物类型识别的总体精度为88.4%,Kappa系数为0.81,玉米、大豆和其他3种地物类型的制图精度分别为93.1%,86.0%和87.3%;没有红边参与的3种地物识别的总体精度为81.7%,Kappa系数为0.71,玉米、大豆和其他3种地区类型的制图精度分别为83.9%,73.4%和84.6%;通过引入红边波段,3种地物的总体识别精度提高了6.7百分点,玉米、大豆和其他3种地物类型的识别精度分别提高了9.2百分点,12.6百分点和2.7百分点。利用JeffriesMatusita方法计算了3种地物的可分性测度,玉米-大豆、玉米-其他、大豆-其他的可分性测度分别由0.84变为1.73、1.37变为1.81、1.27变为1.29;采用破碎度指数计算了景观破碎度,地块数量减少了69.2%,平均地块面积增加了2.2倍,平均地块周长增加了60.50%,地块面积与周长比增加了1.0倍。由上述研究结果可以看出,通过红边波段的引入,增加了地物的间的可分性测度,减少了“椒盐”效应造成的景观破碎度的增加,农作物面积识别整体精度得到了提高。目前搭载红边波段的卫星载荷越来越多,即将发射的国产卫星也拟增加红边波段提高作物识别能力,该文研究结果将为国产红边卫星数据在农业上的应用提供参考。

Liu J, Wang L M, Teng F , et al.

Impact of red-edge waveband of RapidEye satellite on estimation accuracy of crop planting area

[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 2016,32(13):140-148.

Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

Shao Y, Fan X, Liu H , et al.

Rice monitoring and production estimation using multitemporal RADARSAT

[J]. Remote Sensing of Environment, 2001,76(3):310-325.

DOI:10.1016/S0034-4257(00)00212-1      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Rice monitoring and production estimation has special significance to China, as rice is the staple grain and accounts for 42% of the crop production in this country. Radar remote sensing is appropriate for monitoring rice because the areas where this crop is cultivated are often cloudy and rainy. Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) is thus anticipated to be the dominant high-resolution remote sensing data source for agricultural applications in tropical and subtropical regions. It also provides revisit schedules suitable for agricultural monitoring. This paper presents the results of a study examining the backscatter behavior of rice as a function of time using multitemporal RADARSAT data acquired in 1996 and 1997. A rice-type distribution map was produced, showing four types of rice with different life spans ranging from 80 days to 120 125 days. The life span of a rice crop has significant impact on the yield, as well as on the taste and quality of the rice, with the longer growing varieties having the best taste and the highest productivity. The rice production of three counties and two administrative regions, totaling 5000 km 2, was estimated in this study. The accuracy of the rice classification was found to be 91% (97% after postclassification filtering) providing confidence that multitemporal RADARSAT data is capable of rice mapping. An empirical growth model was then applied to the results of the rice classification, which related radar backscatter values to rice life spans. These life spans could then be used to sum up the production estimates, which were obtained from agronomic models already in use for rice by local agronomists. These models related the yield of rice to their life span based on empirical observations for each type of rice. The resulting productivity estimate could not be compared to any other existing data on yield production for the study-area, but was well received by the local authorities. Based on the studies carried out in the Zhaoqing test site since 1993, it is suggested that rice production estimates require three radar data acquisitions taken at three different stages of crop growth and development. These three growth stages are: at the end of the transplanting and seedling development period, during the ear differentiation period, and at the beginning of the harvest period. Alternatively, if multiparameter radar data is available, only two data acquisitions may be needed. These would be at the end of the transplanting and seedling development period, and at the beginning of the harvest period. This paper also proposes an operational scenario for rice monitoring and production estimation.

Arikan M.

Parcel based crop mapping through multi-temporal masking classification of Landsat7 images in Karacabey,Turkey

[C]//Proceedings of the ISPRS Symposium.ISPRS, 2011.

[本文引用: 1]

Kussul N, Lemoine G, Gallego J, et al.

Parcel based classification for agricultural mapping and monitoring using multi-temporal satellite image sequences

[C]//Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium.IEEE, 2015: 165-168.

[本文引用: 1]

贾坤, 李强子 .

农作物遥感分类特征变量选择研究现状与展望

[J]. 资源科学, 2013,35(12):2507-2516.

URL     [本文引用: 2]

农作物遥感分类是农作物种植面积估算的重要核心问题,是提高农作物种植面积估算精度的关键研究内容。特征变量的选择是农作物遥感分类的重要步骤,有效地使用多种特征变量是提高农作物遥感分类精度的关键。随着多源数据获取的更加容易,电磁波谱特征、空间特征、时间特征以及辅助数据特征在农作物遥感分类中发挥着重要的作用。本文简要回顾和综合分析了在农作物遥感分类中所使用的各种特征变量,包括多光谱特征、微波散射特征、多源数据特征、高光谱数据特征等电磁波谱特征,以及空间特征、时间特征和辅助数据特征等,并分析了农作物遥感分类特征变量选择方面存在的问题和发展趋势。指出目前农作物遥感分类特征变量选择存在的关键问题主要包括特征变量选择的理论研究不足和综合应用存在缺陷两个方面。未来农作物遥感分类特征选择研究的核心内容主要包括生化组分特征及冠层结构特征等农作物遥感分类新特征变量的挖掘、分类特征变量的综合应用、农作物遥感分类特征变量的敏感性和不确定性研究3个方面。

Jia K, Li Q Z .

Review of features selection in crop classification using remote sensing data

[J]. Resources Science, 2013,35(12):2507-2516.

[本文引用: 2]

Bolstad P V, Lillesand T M .

Rule-based classification models:Flexible integration of satellite imagery and thematic spatial data

[J]. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 1992,58(7):965-971.

DOI:10.1109/36.158881      URL     [本文引用: 1]

A framework for automated land-cover classification based on a concept of a classification model was developed and tested. The framework employs a user-specified rule base to describe a classification model, defined as the series of spatial data operations and decisions used in landcover classification. Both evidential and hierarchical inference are supported utilizing a set of spatial data operators. The concept was tested through the development and application of a set of computer programs which support classification models. A rule base, thematic spatial data, and satellite image data were then used to define a classification model for conditions in northeastern Wisconsin. The test model incorporated Landsat Thematic Mapper data, soil texture data, and topographic position data. Classification accuracies and efficiencies using the developed system were then compared to those for supervised maximum-likelihood classifications. The classification model approach resulted in statistically significant, 15 percent improvements in classification accuracy when averaged across different analysts, geographic areas, and years.

吴炳方, 刘海燕 .

水稻种植面积估计的运行化遥感方法

[J]. 遥感学报, 1997,1(1):58-63.

DOI:10.11834/jrs.19970109      URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

该文提出了用高分辨率遥感数据提取水稻种值面积本底数据和用可靠低廉的NOAAAVHRR数据估计水稻种植面积变化趋势的方法。该方法具有运行化的特点,成功地应用于1994年度湖北省早稻种植面积估算。

Wu B F, Liu H Y .

The operational methods for rice area estimation using remote sensing

[J]. Journal of Remote Sensing, 1997,1(1):58-63.

Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

Hughes G .

On the mean accuracy of statistical pattern recognizers

[J]. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 1968,14(1):55-63.

DOI:10.1109/TIT.1968.1054102      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Guyon I, Elisseeff A .

An introduction to variable and feature selection

[J]. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 2003,3(6):1157-1182.

DOI:10.1063/1.106515      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Variable and feature selection have become the focus of much research in areas of application for which datasets with tens or hundreds of thousands of variables are available. These areas include text processing of internet documents, gene expression array analysis, and combinatorial chemistry. The objective of variable selection is three-fold: improving the prediction performance of the predictors, providing faster and more cost-effective predictors, and providing a better understanding of the underlying process that generated the data. The contributions of this special issue cover a wide range of aspects of such problems: providing a better definition of the objective function, feature construction, feature ranking, multivariate feature selection, efficient search methods, and feature validity assessment methods.

王娜, 李强子, 杜鑫 , .

单变量特征选择的苏北地区主要农作物遥感识别

[J]. 遥感学报, 2017,21(4):519-530.

DOI:10.11834/jrs.20176373      URL     [本文引用: 1]

遥感识别多源特征综合和特征优选是提高遥感影像分类精度的关键技术。农作物遥感识别中,识别特征的相对单一和数量过多均会导致作物识别精度不理想。随机森林(random forests)采用分类与回归树(CART)算法来生成分类树,结合了bagging和随机选择特征变量的优点,是一种有效的分类方法。单变量特征选择(univariate feature selection)能够对每一个待分类的特征进行测试,衡量该特征和响应变量之间的关系,根据得分舍弃不好的特征,优选得到的特征用于分类。本文基于随机森林和单变量特征选择,利用多时相光谱信息、植被指数信息、纹理信息及波段差值信息,设计多组分类实验方案,对江苏省泗洪县的高分一号(GF-1)和环境一号(HJ-1A)影像进行分类研究,旨在选择最佳的分类方案对实验区主要农作物进行识别和提取。实验结果表明:(1)多源信息综合的农作物分类精度明显高于单一的原始光谱特征分类,说明不同类型特征的引入能改善分类效果;(2)基于单变量特征选择算法的优选特征分类效果最佳,总体精度97.07%,Kappa系数0.96,表明了特征优选在降低维度的同时,也保证了较高的分类精度。随机森林和单变量特征选择结合的方法可以提高遥感影像的分类精度,为农作物的识别和提取研究提供了有效的方法。

Wang N, Li Q Z, Du X , et al.

Identification of main crops based on the univariate features selection in Subei

[J]. Journal of Remote Sensing, 2017,21(4):519-530.

[本文引用: 1]

王乃斌 . 中国小麦遥感动态监测与估产[M]. 北京: 中国科学出版社, 1996.

[本文引用: 1]

Wang N B. Winter Wheat Dynamic Monitoring and Yield Estimation with Remote Sensing in China[M]. Beijing: Chinese Science and Technology Press, 1996.

[本文引用: 1]

Yang C, Everitt J H, Murden D .

Evaluating high resolution SPOT5 satellite imagery for crop identification

[J]. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2011,75(2):347-354.

DOI:10.1016/j.compag.2010.12.012      URL     [本文引用: 1]

High resolution satellite imagery offers new opportunities for crop monitoring and assessment. A SPOT 5 image with four spectral bands (green, red, near-infrared, and mid-infrared) and 10-m pixel size covering intensively cropped areas in south Texas was evaluated for crop identification. Two images with pixel sizes of 20 m and 30 m were also generated from the original image to simulate coarser resolution satellite imagery. Two subset images covering a variety of crops with different growth stages were extracted from the satellite image and four supervised classification techniques, including minimum distance, Mahalanobis distance, maximum likelihood, and spectral angle mapper, were applied to the 10-m subset images and the two coarser resolution images to identify crop types. The effect of the mid-infrared band on classification was also studied. Accuracy assessment showed that the 10-m, four-band images based on maximum likelihood resulted in the best overall accuracy values of 91% and 87% for the two sites. The 20-m and 30-m images had essentially the same accuracy values as the 10-m images, though the inclusion of the mid-infrared band significantly increased classification results. These results indicate that SPOT 5 multispectral imagery can be a useful data source for identifying crop types and estimating crop areas.

赵英时 . 遥感应用分析原理与方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2003.

[本文引用: 2]

Zhao Y S. The Principal and Method of Analysis of Remote Sensing Application[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2003.

[本文引用: 2]

Li Q, Wang C, Zhang B , et al.

Object-based crop classification with Landsat-MODIS enhanced time-series data

[J]. Remote Sensing, 2015,7(12):16091-16107.

DOI:10.3390/rs71215820      URL     [本文引用: 1]

Cropland mapping via remote sensing can provide crucial information for agri-ecological studies. Time series of remote sensing imagery is particularly useful for agricultural land classification. This study investigated the synergistic use of feature selection, Object-Based Image Analysis (OBIA) segmentation and decision tree classification for cropland mapping using a finer temporal-resolution Landsat-MODIS Enhanced time series in 2007. The enhanced time series extracted 26 layers of Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and five NDVI Time Series Indices (TSI) in a subset of agricultural land of Southwest Missouri. A feature selection procedure using the Stepwise Discriminant Analysis (SDA) was performed, and 10 optimal features were selected as input data for OBIA segmentation, with an optimal scale parameter obtained by quantification assessment of topological and geometric object differences. Using the segmented metrics in a decision tree classifier, an overall classification accuracy of 90.87% was achieved. Our study highlights the advantage of OBIA segmentation and classification in reducing noise from in-field heterogeneity and spectral variation. The crop classification map produced at 30 m resolution provides spatial distributions of annual and perennial crops, which are valuable for agricultural monitoring and environmental assessment studies.

Breiman L .

Random forests

[J]. Machine Learning, 2001,45(1):5-32.

DOI:10.1023/A:1010933404324      URL     [本文引用: 2]

Miao X, Heaton J S, Zheng S F , et al.

Applying tree-based ensemble algorithms to the classification of ecological zones using multi-temporal multi-source remote-sensing data

[J]. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 2012,33(6):1823-1849.

DOI:10.1080/01431161.2011.602651      URL     [本文引用: 1]

The decision tree method has grown fast in the past two decades and its performance in classification is promising. The tree-based ensemble algorithms have been used to improve the performance of an individual tree. In this study, we compared four basic ensemble methods, that is, bagging tree, random forest, AdaBoost tree and AdaBoost random tree in terms of the tree size, ensemble size, band selection (BS), random feature selection, classification accuracy and efficiency in ecological zone classification in Clark County, Nevada, through multi-temporal multi-source remote-sensing data. Furthermore, two BS schemes based on feature importance of the bagging tree and AdaBoost tree were also considered and compared. We conclude that random forest or AdaBoost random tree can achieve accuracies at least as high as bagging tree or AdaBoost tree with higher efficiency; and although bagging tree and random forest can be more efficient, AdaBoost tree and AdaBoost random tree can provide a significantly higher accuracy. All ensemble methods provided significantly higher accuracies than the single decision tree. Finally, our results showed that the classification accuracy could increase dramatically by combining multi-temporal and multi-source data set.

张晓羽, 李凤日, 甄贞 , .

基于随机森林模型的陆地卫星-8遥感影像森林植被分类

[J]. 东北林业大学学报, 2016,44(6):53-57.

DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-5382.2016.06.014      URL     [本文引用: 1]

以黑龙江省漠河县为研究区域,采用陆地卫星-8遥感影像为数据源,结合影像的光谱信息和数字高程模型辅助数据,分别采用最大似然分类法(MLC)和随机森林模型法(RFM)对研究区森林植被进行分类,并分析和评价光谱特征变量对模型的重要性、2种分类方法对森林植被类型分类的适用性。结果表明:随机森林分类方法的总体分类精度为81.65%、卡帕(Kappa)系数为0.812。与传统的MLC方法相比,RFM法均提高了3种森林类型的生产者精度和使用者精度,其中针阔混交林精度提高最多。通过分析特征变量的重要性,发现高程、归一化植被指数、红光波段、近红外波段、短波红外波段对模型分类精度有较重要的影响。说明随机森林模型方法结合多源信息是森林植被类型遥感分类的一种有效手段。

Zhang X Y, Li F R, Zhen Z , et al.

Forest vegetation classification of Landsat8 remote sensing image based on random forests model

[J]. Journal of Northeast Forest University, 2016,44(6):53-57.

[本文引用: 1]

Breiman L .

Bagging predictors

[J]. Machine Learning, 1996,24(2):123-140.

[本文引用: 1]

贾坤, 李强子, 田亦陈 , .

遥感影像分类方法研究进展

[J]. 光谱学与光谱分析, 2011,31(10):2618-2623.

DOI:10.3964/j.issn.1000-0593(2011)10-2618-06      URL     Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

Jia K, Li Q Z, Tian Y C , et al.

A review of classification methods of remote sensing imagery

[J]. Spectroscopy and Spectral Analysis, 2011,31(10):2618-2623.

Magsci     [本文引用: 1]

Gu X, Pan Y, He X .

Measurement of sown area of winter wheat based on per-field classification and remote sensing imagery

[J]. Journal of Remote Sensing, 2010,14(4):789-805.

DOI:10.3724/SP.J.1011.2010.01138      URL     [本文引用: 1]

With the significantly improved data availability in remote sensing technology,mid-resolution images have become the primary data source for crop sown area estimation in large scale.However,it is still difficult to solve the problems of spectrum heterogeneity in one field and spectra similarity between fields,especially in transitional region by using mid-resolution images.In order to maximally avoid above motioned problems and accurately measure the sown area of winter wheat,this paper developed per-field classification method and tested the method in an urban agriculture region with complex planting structure through several steps:first,digitalizing field boundary from QuickBird image;second,extracting characteristic index including spectrum and texture information as well as vegetation index for each field from the multi-temporal TM images;third,operating support vector machine(SVM) and maximum likelihood classification(MLC) with different field characteristic index;finally,estimating the accuracy of our method.Results show that the per-field classification method has a higher accuracy than per-pixel classification both in amount(estimated sown area of winter wheat divide by reference sown area of winter wheat,Kr) and position(equal to product accuracy,Kp).Although both SVM and MLC could get very high amount and position accuracy(97% and 90% respectively),the estimations of SVM are more stable.The errors of per-field classification mainly happened at the fragmentized parcels.Additionally,characteristic information could enhance the performance of per-field classification.Our method also has an outstanding advantage that no optimum period requires on satellite imagery which could enhance practicability and operationality of our method.

/

京ICP备05055290号-2
版权所有 © 2015 《自然资源遥感》编辑部
地址:北京学院路31号中国国土资源航空物探遥感中心 邮编:100083
电话:010-62060291/62060292 E-mail:zrzyyg@163.com
本系统由北京玛格泰克科技发展有限公司设计开发